Why pitch-winning ideas are the wrong ideas.
There’s a disturbing trend in clients using pitches to solve problems rather than choose agencies – ie, to find the right idea, not the right agency.
It’s disturbing, because it means they get a lot of good thinking – arguably, our most valuable commodity – for free. That’s not good for agencies. But it’s also not good for clients. Because they get an idea based on a rushed, pitch-frenzy process and therefore a superficial understanding of the brief, the market and the client.
Even worse, the idea you present may be one you’ve developed to impress the client, not solve the problem. As I always say, in a pitch the client is the customer, not their customers. I’ve always been tried to pitch the idea that will win the business first, and answer the brief second. Now that these are one and the same thing, it’s harder and harder for everyone to get it right.